Instagram Pinterest Linkedin-in Envelope
    • Home
    • My Writing Corner
      • Pulse of the World
      • Critique Corner
      • Research Desk
      • Philosophy Symposium
      • Creative Chronicles
    • Lifestyle Collective
      • IN-CAFÉ CINEMA
      • IN-CAFÉ JUKEBOX
      • IN-CAFÉ LIBRARY
      • IN-CAFÉ MAP
    • Open Mic
      • Current Affairs
      • History, Arts & Humanities
      • Science & Technology
      • Philosophy & Stoicism
    • About Me
    • Home
    • My Writing Corner
      • Pulse of the World
      • Critique Corner
      • Research Desk
      • Philosophy Symposium
      • Creative Chronicles
    • Lifestyle Collective
      • IN-CAFÉ CINEMA
      • IN-CAFÉ JUKEBOX
      • IN-CAFÉ LIBRARY
      • IN-CAFÉ MAP
    • Open Mic
      • Current Affairs
      • History, Arts & Humanities
      • Science & Technology
      • Philosophy & Stoicism
    • About Me

    Home » My Writing Corner » Critique Corner » Page 5

    Browsing Category
    Critique Corner
    My Writing Corner Critique Corner

    Cinema as Resistance: How The 2025 Best Picture Nominees Challenge Injustices, Power and Society

    February 26, 2025 No Comments

    Cinema as Resistance: How The 2025 Best Picture Nominees Challenge Injustices, Power and Society

    The fervent race for the Oscars’ most coveted prize -Best Motion Picture of the Year- is often seen as a contest in which victory is claimed by a film that flawlessly executes cinematic excellence by checking every box of artistry, storytelling and technical mastery. However, with cinema’s inherent predisposition to political scepticism, the race for Best Picture is often seen as a stage for quiet rebellion in which ideas compete that mirror the deep-seated issues of society or expose inconsistencies within the film industry. For example, when Parasite shattered barriers in 2020, it was not just a victory for international cinema but a statement against Hollywood’s insular tendencies while providing an avant-gardist perspective on the limits of capitalism. Similarly, following the infamous snub of Brokeback Mountain in 2006, when Moonlight triumphed over La La Land in 2017, it felt like a long-overdue reckoning in which the Academy finally embraced the poignant nature of queer love and sought to oppose the homophobic rhetoric that spurred following the US marriage equality legalisation in 2015. In this piece, I will briefly examine some of most stand-out Best Picture Nominees of 2025 and unravel the political and humanistic themes that linger beneath its frames illustrating how each film delivers a contextually-relevant and ideologically rich message for the world to embrace.

    Contextualising The 2025 Oscar Race

    In 2025, the race for Best Picture unfolds within a whirlwind of controversies, challenges and the absence of a clear front-runner adding layers of mysticism that make this year’s awards season one of the most unpredictable in film history. Furthermore, in an era defined by a resurgent conservative political climate, where the Trump administration’s relentless grip on immigration, artistic expression and minority rights collides with escalating global tensions and the rise of authoritarian-leaning world leaders, an age-old question emerges – To what extent does cinema still have the power to challenge the presence of power within society itself? This year’s Best Picture nominees do not shy away from provocation. From audacious political allegories to deeply intimate narratives, they confront the complexities of our time with a rawness that demands attention. However,  the question on whether cinema still retains its capacity to change the systematic issues it addresses remains a mystery worthy of further exploration. In this list, I compile the most outstanding best picture nominees, from what I have seen, that I believe the most compelling narratives, in order of significance.

    The Brutalist

    The Empty Ambition of “The Brutalist” | The New YorkerThe Brutalist is a monumental masterpiece that could very well earn its respect as one of the greatest and most ambitious films of the 21st century. Directed by Brady Corbet, The Brutalist chronicles the story of László Tóth, a visionary Hungarian-Jewish architect and Holocaust survivor, who, alongside his wife Erzsébet, seeks to reconstruct their lives in post-war America. Their tumultuous journey takes a transformative turn when the enigmatic industrialist Harrison Lee Van Buren offers László a commission that promises to redefine their lives as immigrants and change the paradigm of modern brutalist architecture. This story has been empathetically narrated through the superlative performances of Adrien Brody, Felicity Jones and Guy Pearce who have each been nominated in their respective category. Furthermore, the film also executes technical mastery with a majestic score, production design and cinematography making it a well-round film that I believe is the most worthy of the night’s top prize. Beyond ticking the boxes of cinematic excellence, the film captures the birth of Modern America as it transitions from its old wild western days to a cosmopolitan capitalist urbanscape. This transformation is captured through László’s story, whose attempt to seek freedom in the American Dream is interrupted when he confronts the gritty realism of US Capitalism that hurts the people living on the fringes of society.

    It is through László’s professional relationship with Harrison Lee Van Buren in building a community centre that he navigates the evils of materialism, institutionalism, exploitation and cultural homogenisation as he resists compromising his artistic freedom in the name of corporate greed which proves to a bitter journey with many twists and turns. The film’s finale features László’s final building, a brutalist masterpiece, that embodies the outcomes of America’s transformation – designed with the dimensions of a concentration camp to symbolise economic oppression, a cross at the ceiling to reflect spiritual decline, glass ceilings to expose the illusion of free thought, a hollow core representing the emptiness of the American Dream, labyrinthine hallways signifying bureaucratic entrapment, and vertical stratification that mirrors USA;s class divide. All in all, The Brutalist is well-round film with ideologically rich themes that critique USA’s social and political architecture which comes at a time in which people are beginning to question the limits of capitalism and corporate greed. Therefore, in my opinion, this film is the most worthy of the top prize and with a budget of US$10 million, this signifies a remarkable achievement in independent film history.

    The Substance

    The Substance: Amazon.de: Quaid, Dennis, Moore, Demi, Qualley, Margaret,  Balderrama, Joseph, Knight, Daniel, Garcia, Hugo Diego, Lesage, Oscar,  Fargeat, Coralie, Quaid, Dennis, Moore, Demi: DVD & Blu-rayAnother stand-out feature is The Substance, an inventive body-horror masterpiece that brutally tackles issues of body image, industrial beauty standards and aging through a feminine perspective whilst critiquing the power play between artists, producers and shareholders. Directed by Coralie Fargeat, The Substance delves into the harrowing journey of Elisabeth Sparkle, portrayed by Demi Moore, a once-celebrated Hollywood starlet who, upon being dismissed from her long-standing aerobics show due to ageism, resorts to a clandestine drug promising rejuvenation. This experimental serum bifurcates her existence, birthing a younger alter ego named Sue, portrayed by Margaret Qualley. Bound by the stringent “seven-day rule” Elisabeth and Sue must alternate consciousness weekly; failure to adhere results in catastrophic physical degeneration. It is an out-of-the-box and monumental achievement that a film that oddly reflects the style and principles of French Extremity Body Horror is being recognised by the academy. Fargeat masterfully executes her vision alongside superlative performances by Demi Moore and Margaret Qualley as well as technical mastery in fields like editing, score and makeup and hairstyling. Through her unprecedented film, Fargeat’s message remains straightforward in rendering the internal violence women have against their bodies when their self image fails to remain congruent with their ideal image that is socially-constructed to reflect the absurd beauty standards of society, which in the film’s case is being specifically highlighted with regards to the Hollywood Film industry.

    A fundamental prerequisite to truly grasping this film lies in recognising that Sue and Elisabeth, while inhabiting a single physical form, exist as dualistic manifestations of the human consciousness that are constantly vying for control. These manifestations operate one at a time within a dichotomous environment in which their conflicting desires lead to the downfall of the entire physical form. Elisabeth, representing the older entity, envies her younger self and desires to equalise two entities in terms of physical appearance by binge-eating which deteriorates her appearance. Meanwhile,  Sue, representing the younger entity, resents her older self and desires to side-line her presence by forcibly disobeying the 7 day rule. This realisation reflects the inner conflict that plagues our minds when we evaluate the congruency between our self and ideal images whilst rendering the achievement of body satisfaction as a vicious cycle that is difficult to escape. While the film brims with layered symbolism, intricate motifs, and bold cinematic, its essence remains unwavering. At its core, the film critiques the obsession women develop over their bodies as result of a societal narrative that commodifies youth, punishes aging, and pressures individuals to reshape themselves to remain desirable. Through its haunting imagery and psychological depth, Fargeat has set the record straight in calling us recognise the conflicts that punctuate within our consciousness as we evaluate our self-image and seek to action any incongruencies. 

    Emilia Pérez

    How Emilia Pérez's Opening Song, 'El Alegato,' Came TogetherFrance’s submission to the Oscars, Emilia Pérez, is another outstanding endeavour that establishes itself in cinematic history as a resilient film that defies categorisation. Directed by Jacques Audiard, Emilia Pérez weaves the gripping tale  Rita, a brilliant yet struggling lawyer, who finds herself entangled in a dangerous Mexican underworld when she is hired by a cartel leader, Manitas, who seeks her expertise in faking his death and transitioning into a woman, Emilia Pérez, in order to escape his life of crime and undo his past wrongdoings. Instantly, we are introduced to a morally questionable premise in which a fundamentally immoral character is granted a redemption arc working against the laws of morality. Despite being hailed and embraced by industry guilds, Emilia Pérez faced waves of controversy, criticised for its perceived lack of authentic Mexican and transgender representation, sparking heated debates over cultural appropriation and the reinforcement of harmful stereotypes. However, I believe the outrage over this film stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of the film’s core humanistic themes as we operate within a divisive political environment in which we overemphasise cultural and political correctness over empathising with the narrative of a film. At its heart, I believe Emilia Pérez is one of the most bold and provocative films of the 21st century that deserves its many accolades and honours irrespective of the outrage.

    One of Emilia Pérez’s most distinctive features is its refusal to conform to a single genre, defying conventional categorisation. Originally structured as an opera, the film boldly merges a wide array of cinematic styles, from musical and soap opera to telenovela, crime-thriller and drama. This eclectic fusion creates a vibrant yet unpredictable narrative, marking it as one of the most unique and ambitious films in recent memory. However, if I were to categorise Emilia Pérez, I would classify it on the basis of its ideological richness as an existential thriller, delving deep into the complexities of identity, transformation and the profound consequences of self-reinvention. One of Emilia Pérez’s most captivating aspects is its refusal to conform to a single genre, defying conventional categorization. Originally structured as an opera, the film boldly merges a wide array of cinematic styles, from musical and soap opera to telenovela, crime-thriller, and drama. This eclectic fusion creates a vibrant yet unpredictable narrative, marking it as one of the most unique and ambitious films in recent memory. As Zoë Saldaña eloquently states, beyond its gripping, plot-driven premise, Emilia Pérez is, at its core, a story of four women fighting to claim their radical freedom and become the most authentic versions of themselves, escaping a life lived in bad faith. For one, it means breaking free from the grip of crime and seeking redemption; for another, it is the pursuit of financial stability, the search for love after deep trauma, or the simple yet profound act of self-acceptance. Yet, not all of them reach their true selves, and in their struggle, the film unveils a painful truth. Emilia Pérez is ultimately a meditation on identity, exposing the dire consequences of denying one’s essence while urging us to find empathy – even for those who exist in the darkest corners of society.

    Conclave

    Review of Film “Conclave,” Now Streaming on Peacock - Hollywood ProgressiveConclave, directed by Edward Berger, offers an intimate glimpse into the secretive world of the Vatican’s papal election, weaving a narrative rich in suspense and character complexity. The papal thriller begins with the sudden death of the Pope, prompting the College of Cardinals to convene in a secluded conclave to elect his successor. Among the prominent contenders are Cardinal Aldo Bellini (Stanley Tucci), a progressive voice advocating for modernization; Cardinal Joshua Adeyemi (John Lithgow), a socially conservative figure with a strong moral stance; Cardinal Joseph Tremblay (Ralph Fiennes), representing moderate views; and Cardinal Goffredo Tedesco (Sergio Castellitto), a staunch traditionalist yearning for a return to old rituals. The arrival of the mysterious Archbishop Vincent Benitez (Isabela Rossellini), appointed secretly by the late Pope, adds an unexpected twist to the proceedings. As the cardinals navigate political manoeuvring, personal revelations and ethical dilemmas, the film masterfully portrays the tension and gravity of their decision-making process. The narrative is further enriched by stunning cinematography that captures the grandeur of the Vatican and a haunting score that underscores the film’s dramatic moments. Conclave has garnered critical acclaim for its compelling storytelling and exceptional performances, earning it a place among the notable Best Picture nominees at the 2025 Academy Awards.

    Beyond its intricate plot, Conclave delves into profound ideological themes, reflecting the broader liberal and conservative divide that characterizes contemporary society and especially in the USA where it plays out as a “culture war”. The film’s portrayal of the papal election serves as a microcosm of today’s political landscape, highlighting the clash between progressive ideals and traditional values within the Church. Cardinal Bellini’s push for modernization mirrors the liberal agenda for inclusivity and reform, while Cardinal Tedesco’s traditionalism echoes conservative calls for a return to foundational principles. This ideological tug-of-war is further complicated by personal ambitions and hidden agendas, mirroring the political polarisation evident in the 2024  US Presidential election. The film also addresses issues of identity and authenticity, particularly through the character of Archbishop Benitez, whose unexpected presence challenges the status quo and forces the cardinals to confront their biases and preconceptions. Conclave thus not only provides a gripping narrative but also prompts viewers to reflect on the complexities of leadership, the challenges of ideological polarisation and the enduring struggle between tradition and progress in shaping the future of institutions. In a digital age in which political beliefs divide us, Conclave asks us to reassess our belief systems and embrace difference, uncertainty and the diversity of though as higher virtues.

    Anora

    Anora Trailer: One Of 2024's Most Acclaimed Movies Gets New Look Ahead Of  October ReleaseOur final stand-out feature and the predicted winner of the best picture race, Anora, directed by Sean Baker, is a compelling comedy-drama that delves into the complexities of love, power and class within the vibrant Russian-American community of Brighton Beach. The film follows Ani, portrayed by Mikey Madison, a naïve lap dancer whose life takes an unexpected turn when she marries Vanya, the son of a Russian oligarch. This union propels Ani into a world of opulence and intrigue, challenging her perceptions and resilience. Baker’s direction seamlessly blends elements of screwball comedy with social realism, creating a narrative that is both entertaining and thought-provoking. The film’s authenticity is further enhanced by its diverse New York settings, capturing the essence of the city’s multifaceted culture. Madison’s performance has been widely acclaimed, earning her a BAFTA award and an Academy Award nomination for Best Actress. Anora has also achieved significant box office success, grossing over $40 million worldwide, a testament to its broad appeal and critical acclaim.

    Beyond its engaging plot, Anora addresses profound ideological themes, shedding light on the intricacies of the sex industry and the human stories within it. The film treats sex work with respect and empathy, challenging societal stigmas and offering a nuanced portrayal of those within the profession. Ani’s relationship with Vanya underscores the transactional nature of certain relationships, prompting viewers to reflect on power dynamics and authenticity in human connections. The stark class divide between Ani’s modest upbringing and Vanya’s wealth highlights societal disparities, emphasising the challenges individuals face when crossing socioeconomic boundaries. Anora invites audiences to empathize with characters often marginalised, encouraging a deeper understanding of their struggles and aspirations.  While the film displays its themes it full lights, in my opinion, it is the weakest of all nominees in that it lacks any form of depth or substance that would have enhance the film’s thematic portrayal of its issue. Nevertheless, excluding its R-rated explicit scene, it is a film that can be delivered to diverse audience whose message can be easily digested at the surface level.

     

    Continue reading
    Written by: Mineka
    My Writing Corner Critique Corner

    Diogenes Unplugged: 7 Philosophical Stunts That Combine Truth & Wit

    February 6, 2025 No Comments

    Diogenes Unplugged: 7 Philosophical Stunts That Combine Truth & Wit

    When we think of the Ancient Greek philosophical pantheon, names like Socrates, Aristotle, and Plato inevitably come to mind. These intellectual missionaries laid the bedrock of Western thought, crafting ideas and allegories that still drive the engines of academia today. However, amidst this elite philosophical assembly, one figure stands out like a sore thumb at a toga party: Diogenes of Sinope (404-323 BC)1. Born in the 4th century BCE, he was the son of the infamous Tresius, a wealthy money-changer, whose adulterous and fraudulent activities forced him and his family to be exiled from Sinope to Athens. There, Diogenes lived his life as a mendicant, choosing to shelter himself in a ceramic barrel by the Temple of Cybele, where he transformed his life of poverty to virtue by embracing philosophy in a peculiar sense1. Today, he is regarded as one of the leading proponents of Cynicism, a school of thought that emphasised living in virtuous agreement with nature, rejecting societal conventions and avoiding material excess.

    The peculiarity of Diogenes’s characterisation as a philosopher stems from the methods he chose to express his cynical ideas. While Socrates was busy questioning everything in sight and Plato was off in his ideal world crafting perfect forms, Diogenes was more concerned with turning the whole philosophical exercise into a comedic spectacle. Unlike his contemporaries who practiced traditional teaching methods, Diogenes chose to exercise his philosophical propositions  through hilarious stunts that shocked the streets of free-speech-loving Athens. Unashamed by the defiance of social norms, these humorous stunts reverberate deep ideas that continue to be relevant to this day. From the very act of living in a barrel to his infamous lantern and mocking of Plato, I count down in this list 10 of my favourite philosophical stunts by Diogenes and what I believe their philosophical underpinnings might be.

    1. The Barrel Affair

    One of Diogenes’s most stand-out stunts was his enduring choice to live life in a large ceramic jar (affectionately referred to as a barrel in popular culture). Although one would rationalise this choice as exemplification of his exposure to poverty, it is impossible to assume that a man as ingenious as Diogenes would not make a conscious choice to live in barrel. This very act has continued to stand the test of time and has inspired thinkers to this day. Famously in 2007, during Dutch Philosophy week, philosopher, Eric Hoekstra emulated Diogenes by living the week in a barrel in order to highlight the essence of living a life that is free from the complex idiosyncrasies, constructs and trappings that define the contemporary era2.

    Similar to Hoekstra’s stunt, Diogenes’ lifestyle choice shares similar philosophical underpinnings. As a cynic, his simple living choice questions the necessity of luxury and exuberance in sustaining a mortal human life. His message remains more evident than ever in the contemporary era that is often characterised by materialism and decadence from our infatuation with physical objects and desire to conform to the norms and constructs of the modern world.  Diogenes reminds us to question the futility of our materialistic desires and free ourselves from living a sheltered existence in a calculated society. His message remains more relatable that ever to the elites of Ancient Greece as the elites of today, whose extravagant hedonistic lifestyles are hindered by an inner emptiness and desire for simplicity that one would forever remain unrealised. His simplistic choice embodies this cynical philosophy and establishes the school’s fundamental answer on how to live a mortal human life.  

    2. The Daylight Lantern

    Another one of his clever stunts, was his daylight lantern, a frequent spectacle that involved Diogenes walking the sunny streets of Athens with a well-lit lantern. When questioned by onlookers of his bizarre behaviour, his response was that he was looking for an ‘honest man’. There is a current historic debate on the exact words he stated with some experts suggesting that he was looking for a ‘man’ or ‘human’ or any other word choice that reflects the idea of humanity3. This lexical dispute leads to two interrelated interpretations that I believe collectively convey the essence of his ingenious act.

    If Diogenes was indeed looking for an honest man, it is palpable that he was highlighting the severe lack of authenticity and honesty in a society that is constrained by norms and constructs. By choosing to search this inexistent man in broad daylight, he highlights the scarcity of honesty and how it is instilled through society where people choose to act and enslave themselves to a status quo whilst jeopardising their own exercise of freedom. His choice to conduct this search with a lit lamp only further accentuates the gravity and relevance of his philosophical message to Athenian society that was at times stricken by instances of bad faith,

    However, if we shift gears and focus on the second historic argument in that Diogenes was in search for a ‘human’ or ‘humanity’, it seems that he was questioning the very definition of humanity and how it was applied and practiced by the citizens of Athens. One could argue that his search for humanity was synonymous to an ordinary man’s quest for meaning as he climbs the ladder of life. However, his inability to search one, despite being in daylight with a lamp, serves as stark reflection on how many of us choose to live against the forces that strives us to find meaning in life and self-actualise. Consequently, Diogenes’s idea of the ‘honest man’ is more synonymous to a ‘genuine man’, a man whose quest for meaning is derived by his intrinsic desires as opposed to the expectations of society emphasising the importance of humans to self-actualise and celebrate their inner genuine self.

    3. Don’t block my sunlight!

    Many of the stunts mentioned thus so far were undoubtedly eccentric and wise but were relatively simple to translate actions to substance. The following stunt, however, is brief and implicit but carries profound axiological undertones. This is the tale of the day when the mighty King of Macedon, Alexander the Great, on an expedition to Corinth, encountered Diogenes, as usual, living life in his infamous barrel.

    According to Plutarch’s writings, Alexander, having been educated by Aristotle, had himself become a fervent lover of wisdom and was thrilled to meet the iconoclastic Diogenes at the time. On that fateful day, Alexander approached the man whilst he was bathing in his barrel and in a brief yet memorable exchange, Alexander asked Diogenes if there was any favour he could grant him. Diogenes, reclining in his barrel, looked up and simply replied, “Move a little to the right; you are blocking my sun”. With a thoughtful smile and an expression of sudden clarity, Alexander then declared, “If I were not Alexander, then I should wish to be Diogenes”, subsequently granting his trivial request4.

    This encounter represents a profound juxtaposition between two towering figures of antiquity: an ambitiously intelligent conqueror and a sagacious, ascetic philosopher. The stark contrast in their worldviews is immediately evident through our pre-conceived notions of both, and their humorous exchange illuminates several of Diogenes’s cynic philosophies. In essence, Diogenes extols simplicity as the highest virtue and his impudence to face the most powerful man in the Hellenistic world in such a casual manner. Diogenes positions himself as equal to Alexander and rejects the idea of titles and demographic markers that disrupt our humanistic need to bond with fellow humans. Alexander, despite his own grand pursuits, profoundly understands and acknowledges the wisdom in Diogenes’s words by fulfilling his simple request.

    Furthermore, Diogenes’s emphasis on the ‘sun’ serves as a potent symbol of nature and the elemental needs of human life, urging us to reconnect with and celebrate the simple pleasures derived from nature. This interaction is thereby a  timeless lesson that underscores the value of simplicity and contentment over the relentless pursuit of power and wealth by contrasting two juxtaposing figures in the history of Ancient Greece. As we navigate the complexities of modern existence, Diogenes’s message remains strikingly relevant: true fulfilment maybe found in the simple pleasures delivered by nature. In a world that is increasingly plagued by materialism and technological encroachment, we can revert to modest natural pleasures by the sounds of water gushing through fractured rocks or sun rays falling over a verdant vista of hills.

    4. The Silence of the Statues

    There are no limits to the eccentricity and ingeniousness of Diogenes’s philosophical stunts. Here is another peculiar one… Begging for food and money from statues. Diogenes would stand before the statues of gods and illustrious figures in public spaces, extending his hand and imploring them for alms5. Once again, his persistent pleas to these inanimate objects highlighted his willingness to engage in actions that defied conventional logic and decorum. However as accustomed as we are to Diogenes’ style of wisdom, we know this too was far from a meaningless stunt; it was a deliberate philosophical exercise that carried a deeper, profound message.

    The underlying philosophy of begging from statues was a sharp critique of human behaviour. By choosing statues as the recipients of his pleas, Diogenes illustrated the futility of seeking help or validation from those who cannot provide it. This act paralleled the often-fruitless efforts of humans seeking approval from indifferent or incapable sources. Just as statues are lifeless and unresponsive, so too are many of the entities from which people seek validation- be it societal institutions, material wealth or superficial relationships. Diogenes’s actions underscored his cynic ideals of self-sufficiency and independence from societal expectations. He demonstrated that true strength and contentment come from within, rather than from external approval or assistance. Through this witty act, Diogenes challenged individuals to reconsider their dependencies and to cultivate a life grounded in self-reliance and inner fulfilment. This is key ideological fixture within cynicism and is indeed relevant in the present day, where external validation remains a key constituent of identity formation that has subsequently obscured us from our genuine self and our ability to stay independent and free.

    5. The Featherless Chicken

     

    Diogenes, our iconoclast, is also known for challenging his fellow philosophers at time who were ever-so infatuated with defining the metaphysics of reality through what he would have described as an absurd and ludicrous approach to inquiry. One of his most despised institutions would have been the Platonic academy where Plato himself had one day merely defined humanity as ‘featherless bipeds’ thus commanding Diogenes to perform yet again another philosophical stunt.   In this provocative act, Diogenes was said to have entered the platonic academy with a featherless chicken and proudly declaring “Here is Plato’s human!6” This audacious act, which at first seemed like a mere joke or a mockery of philosophical discourse and was so influential that Plato himself was compelled to revise his definition of humanity.

    The underlying message of Diogenes’s plucked chicken was to critique the superficial and abstract thinking instilled by the institutions of the time. By presenting the featherless bird as a “human” Diogenes exposed the inadequacy of defining humanity through theoretical thought experiments and reducing complex entities to narrow descriptions comprised of a few simple words.  It emphasises the importance of looking beyond superficial attributes to understand the true nature of complex concepts as opposed to over-intellectualising and fetishizing them for the sake of pedagogy or philosophy.  The holistic approach to understanding life through experience and living is what Diogenes advocates as the most ideal way to gage metaphysical concepts. This anecdote remains relevant to date, questioning figures in the academic field to seek deeper, more meaningful and more pragmatic definitions of complex phenomena that shrouding them in meaningless imagery and abstract thought that would never be understood by the layman.

    6. Living Life Like a Dog

     
    Diogenes is said to have lived life like a dog as the Athenians would says.  He was known for his habit of scavenging for food, much like a stray dog. He would roam the streets, searching for discarded scraps and openly consuming whatever he found, regardless of how it might be perceived by others. This behaviour also said to have extended including acts such as urinating in public and masturbating on the streets of Athens7.

    The philosophy behind Diogenes’s ‘dog-like’ existence where he chose to make private acts a public spectacle is once again one of his many cynic metaphors.  By aligning himself with the natural, unpretentious behaviour of dogs, Diogenes sought to demonstrate the transformation of humans from lawless animals to tamed beings highlighting a disparity that underscores the impact of societal norms and constructs in giving humans their new identity. By doing so , Diogenes reminds us that despite our complex human evolution we are still indifferent to animals and carry the same basic instincts, needs and desires which we must sometimes confronted in times of morally ambiguity. Therefore, Diogenes’s adoption of this lifestyle was a deliberate commentary on the false currency of morality and societal norms, which he saw as barriers to empathising with humans when we face scenarios where established morals are questioned and human instincts come into fruition. 

    7. King or Slave?

    We close this list with  one of the most striking of Diogenes’ philosophical stunts, this one involving human bones, slaves and once again the King of Macedon.  According to Plutarch’s accounts, one ordinary day, Diogenes set foot on a marketplace where he was meticulously digging through a pile of human bones which attracted the stares of a few daily grocers. When asked what he was searching for, presumably by Alexander himself, he reportedly replied, “I am looking for the bones of your father (Philip of Macedon), but I cannot distinguish them from those of a slave”8.A deeply macabre and bone chilling act but nevertheless another one of his erudite stunts. 

    Diogenes’s search for bones was not a literal quest but a symbolic commentary on human equality and the futility of social distinctions making it one of his most progressive messages that surpasses the intellect of the time where inequality was weaved through the Hellenistic social fabric. By sifting through bones to find those of a king but unable to distinguish them from those of a slave, Diogenes was highlighting the inherent equality of all humans beyond their social status and roles. He highlights that in the face of death, all human distinctions become meaningless irrespective of whether they are by gender, status, wealth or role. It serves as a direct challenge to the social hierarchies and pretensions of his time, emphasising that material and social distinctions are ultimately irrelevant when faced with the fundamental truths of human mortality.

    Diogenes’s bone-searching incident serves as a timeless reminder of the ephemeral nature of social status and material wealth. In today’s context, where societal divisions and the pursuit of status often overshadow our common humanity, Diogenes’s message is particularly relevant. It encourages us to recognise the inherent equality of all individuals and to reflect on the true value of our actions and judgments. By acknowledging the inherent sameness in all people, we can foster a more equitable and compassionate society, transcending superficial distinctions and focusing on shared human experiences and values.

    There we go! 7 Philosophical stunts performed by Diogenes that despite being comedic gold hint erudite messages that are still relevant to modern-day as much as ancient humans. Since this is an article on Diogenes, let me end it by rejecting the academic convention of writing a conclusion and leave it to you synthesise and concatenate the wisdom and comedy of Diogenes’ stunts. He remains my favourite Classical philosopher and an eloquent reminder of how simplicity, honesty and equality among many others are great virtues that define humanity.

    REFERENCES

    1Diogenes of Sinope. (n.d.). In Internet Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Retrieved July 22, 2024, from https://iep.utm.edu/diogenes-of-sinope/

    2Cook, W. (2007, April 5). The philosopher of fun. The Guardian. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/theguardian/2007/apr/05/features11.g2

    3Zaretsky, R. (2016, Spring). Looking for an honest man. National Affairs. Retrieved from https://www.nationalaffairs.com/publications/detail/looking-for-an-honest-man

    4Panagopoulos, A. (2023, October 18). The meeting of Alexander the Great and Diogenes the Cynic: A clash of philosophy and power. Greek Reporter. Retrieved from https://greekreporter.com/2023/10/18/alexander-great-diogenes-philosophy/

    5Grout, J. (n.d.). Diogenes the Cynic. Encyclopaedia Romana. Retrieved July 22, 2024, from https://penelope.uchicago.edu/~grout/encyclopaedia_romana/greece/hetairai/diogenes.html#:~:text=Asked%20why%20he%20begged%20in,hunger%20by%20rubbing%20one’s%20stomach

    6Saul, H. (2016, April 4). Of Socrates, cynics and flat-nailed featherless bipeds. The New York Times. Retrieved from https://archive.nytimes.com/opinionator.blogs.nytimes.com/2016/04/04/of-socrates-cynics-and-flat-nailed-featherless-bipeds/

    7Martin, D. (2023, June 1). Diogenes the Cynic: A Socrates gone mad? Psychology Today. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/au/blog/hide-and-seek/202306/diogenes-the-cynic-a-socrates-gone-mad#:~:text=After%20being%20exiled%20from%20his,the%20false%20currency%20of%20morality

    8Tsakonas, A. (2023, January 1). Diogenes of Sinope and Alexander the Great: A study of philosophical confrontation. Strategos History. Retrieved from https://www.strategoshistory.com

     

    Continue reading
    Written by: Mineka
    My Writing Corner Critique Corner Photoshootings

    Unravelling the Philosophical Pantheon

    January 1, 2025 No Comments


    UNRAVELLING THE PHILOSOPHICAL PANTHEON

     
    Analysing Raphael’s School of Athens Through His Depiction of His Philosophers

    “The School of Athens” by Raphael (1509) stands as one of the pinnacle achievements in art and tapestry, proudly displayed in the upper reaches of the Vatican. This masterpiece resonates with the wisdom, knowledge, and intellectualism that permeated through Classical Antiquity from 500 BCE to 476 AD, immortalising a congregation of some of the greatest Greek philosophers whose ideas, predictions, and theories laid the foundation of Western civilization. These philosophers casually convene in a grand basilica with an arched lacunar ceiling inspired by the Byzantine-era churches built under Constantine.

    The basilica’s backdrop, adorned with statues of Apollo and Athena on rectangular columns, not only echoes the architectural legacy of Hellenistic culture but also represents a synthesis of Renaissance and ancient architectural styles. This setting mirrors elements of St. Peter’s Basilica and other architectural landmarks of the Vatican, bridging Ancient Greece with the modern West. The inclusion of Apollo and Athena amplifies the message, as these deities symbolize various aspects central to the advancement of Western culture, including dance, war, music, and freedom.

    At the exact centre of the basilica, framed by an arched Doric doorway, stand Aristotle and Plato engaged in conversation, dominating the congregation. Raphael likely cantered these figures to highlight what he perceived as the greatest thinkers of their time, who embody a dichotomy of thought. Their gestures divide the painting into two main schools of thought: Plato’s upward-pointing hand signifies his spiritual and metaphysical approach, suggesting a belief in higher powers and abstract forms. In contrast, Aristotle’s horizontally extended hand symbolizes his empirical and scientific approach grounded in observation and logic. This division underscores the duality of philosophical inquiry.

    Analysing the gestures, actions, and positions of all the philosophers in the painting is complex. However, focusing on the most significant figures, we note the presence of Pythagoras, Hypatia, Archimedes, Diogenes, Euclid, and Alexander the Great. Art historians often debate their identities due to the intricacy of Raphael’s work, resulting in only educated guesses.

    For instance, the figure reclining on the basilica steps is believed to be Diogenes. His posture and representation reflect his rejection of social conventions and luxury. Diogenes’ simple blue chiton robe and relaxed position contrast with the formality and attire of his fellow philosophers, signalling his disdain for material excess and social norms, embodying his quest for authenticity and simplicity.

    Nearby, Pythagoras, the father of mathematics, is depicted surrounded by intrigued students. An image of the Pythagorean triangle is visible, while the text beneath emphasizes his harmonic theory of music, highlighting the sacredness of the number 10 in Western music and religion. Pythagorean mathematics is portrayed as a powerful language essential for understanding the universe’s patterns and mysteries.

    To the right of Pythagoras sits Hypatia of Alexandria, a prominent female mathematician and philosopher. Hypatia, a proponent of Neoplatonism, explored the universe’s supreme goodness through mathematics and astronomy. Tragically, her work was deemed heretical by extreme Christian mobs, leading to her brutal murder. Raphael subtly hints at her tragic story through her attire and expression, alluding emotionally to her loss within the philosophical pantheon.

    Opposite Hypatia and Pythagoras, Euclid is engaged in teaching geometry. Some modern sources suggest this figure could represent Archimedes, reflecting ongoing historical debate. Both philosophers were devoted to scientific inquiry as a means to enhance humanity’s understanding and control of the natural world. Archimedes, known for his inventions, exemplifies the practical application of science.

    Above these figures, Socrates teaches the warrior Alcibiades, one of his infamous students who supposedly engaged in a pederastic relationship. Socrates’ focus on teaching, despite Alcibiades’ irritable expression, portrays him as patient and dedicated to imparting wisdom to his followers, regardless of emotional constraints.

    Many other philosophers populate this artistic masterpiece, each contributing to its depth and complexity. Figures like Socrates, Anaximander, and Alexander the Great are depicted in natural poses, engaging with others. The vastness and intricacy of “The School of Athens” encapsulate the intellectual fervour and dynamism that originated in Classical Greece and Antiquity, ultimately shaping the Western world.

    Despite its Church perspective, Raphael employs Renaissance colour palettes and subtle gestures to convey controversial narratives. This timeless artwork engages in a profound dialogue on philosophy, celebrating the enduring legacy of ancient thought. These are my preliminary ideas guided by factual evidence that encapsulate the essence of this tapestry.

    Continue reading
    Written by: Mineka
    Critique Corner My Writing Corner

    The Indulgence of Italian Imagery: Lyrical Analysis of Lana Del Rey’s ‘Salvatore’

    July 22, 2024 No Comments

    The Indulgence of Italian Imagery: Lyrical Analysis of Lana Del Rey’s ‘Salvatore’

    This song evokes the memories of an American city girl, once naïve to love, as she reminisces about the intimate, passionate, and sensual experiences she shared with her lover during an Italian summer. As she descends into a state of mild depression, she mends her depressive and nostalgic thoughts in an ethereal manner by finding magic, passion, and beauty in her sadness. She almost indulges in and delves into her personal misery in an enigmatic yet mystically magical way. The following analysis unveils these insights.

    All the lights in Miami begin to gleam– The brightly shining lights of Miami serve as a memento, retrieving the grandeur of memories from that Italian summer she shared with her Romeo. Their gleaming power may be symbolic of the Italian summer sun and its role in dispersing the intimate energy that radiates across the Mediterranean region.
    Ruby, blue and green, neon too – Colour imagery reflects and resonates the colours of Italy with ruby-coloured houses and hamlets, blue bodies of water and green cypress trees that ornately embellished the neon green meadows of Tuscany.
    Everything looks better- Hyperbole to reflect her deep sense of appreciation towards the beauty of Italy from above my king Allusion to her enigmatic lover indicating their patronage of an elegantly rich and almost regal relationship in Italy.
    Like aqua marine, ocean’s blue – While the colour symbolism maybe an extended metaphor to elongate the ethereal and enchanting beauty of Summer Italy, it may also be symbolic to the onset of her depressive symptoms where blue elicits an unconscious sensation of desolation as the nostalgia she experiences is met with a silently sweeping desperate sense of longing and despair triggering mild depression.

    Ah ah ah ah
    Ah ah ah ah – Onomatopoeic lexical choices evocate the passionate flow of her thought as she continues to reminisce the delightful and nostalgic memories while simultaneously experiencing the coincident feelings of grief and desperation as a result of her train of thought. In one lens, the words may mimic the sound of quivering as she deals with the perpetual loss of such nostalgic memories or, through another lens, it may envision her indulgence in misery as she savours the amalgamation of sadness and nostalgia rather than agonising it like most humans thus accepting her emotional states as pleasant or unpleasant as they are.
    Cacciatore – Allusions to her lover, possible words she might have learned been thrown into the lyrics to illustrate the unsystematic randomness yet beautiful manner through which her train of though is flowing. Cacciotore meaning ‘Hunter’ is a symbolism of a person who provides and is adventurous which may reflect the nature of her lover and how she appreciates this manly quality.
    La da da da da
    La da da da da – Further onomatopoeic sounds and lexis that connects the flow of her thoughts by expressing her medley of feelings and emotions comprised of ecstasy, nostalgia, grief and dreaminess.
    Limousines – She may have driven around Italy in her Romeo’s limousines which visually deconstructs the image of a rich and regal lifestyle which she lived through with her lover that Summer. These words are also expressions of freedom, in this case the freedom to spread apart in the space of a limousine, which maybe constrained or lacking in her current American life as opposed to that one Italian summer.               

    Ah ah ah ah
    Ah ah ah ah
    Ciao amore
    La da da da da
    La da da da da
    Soft ice cream – Visual Image of Ice cream connotes Italian gelato once again showing the random yet ethereal flow of her train of though as she jumps from one memento to another all weaves and knitted together with nostalgic, ecstasy and grief. The soft ice cream may further symbolise the sensual intimacy and voluptuous memories she would have shared with her lover from classic caressing, passionate pecks and many more.

    All the lights are sparkling for you it seems – Structural change from gleaming to sparkling lights illustrates the transitioning from seeing Italy to her Lover in her visions. As she ponders upon the handsome, well-built and enchanting silhouette of her lover the lights of Miami sparkle in her mind as her eyes are lit and consumed by her attraction towards just as the first time they would’ve met in Italy.
    On the downtown scenes, shady blue– Lexical Choices like “down” “shady” and “blue” lie in the semantic field of depression reinforcing that while she is consumed by the cerebral appearance of her lover and aesthetically pleasured by the beauty of Italy, she is still undergoing a concurrent feeling of misery and loss that she battles with by indulging in it.
    Beatboxing and rapping in the summer rain
    Like a boss – Simile of Talent and Experience , he sang Jazz and Blues – Transitioning from the materialisation of her lover she diverts her attention to his excellent skill in music. Musical lexis like “Jazz” and “Blue” coincidentally give birth to auditory images of romantic sounds in the rain signifying another passionate and intimate memory that means a lot to her.

    Chorus (Repeat)

    The summer’s hot – May have a multitude of meanings, maybe it is that the summer of Italy was hot bought in literal as well as euphemistic sexual terms as well as the summer she is currently expediting in Miami. However, the word “Hot” may be implicit symbol of another emotion that is growing within her which maybe anger and furiousness of having distanced with her lover and not being bale to relive these passionate memories.

    And I’ve been waiting for you all this time – Signifies that she has been waiting for his return but never satisfied her desire indicating possible perpetual loss and distance from her lover? A growing sense of anger?
    I adore you, can’t you see – Direct Address to Lover, questions his common sense and consciousness as it changes the tone of these lyrics from a light-hearted to a more defensive, furious and distressed tone indicating her increasing mental pain and pressure., you’re meant for me?
    Summer’s hot but I’ve been cold without you – Juxtaposing images of coldness and heat adds to the combination of both her grief and growing sense of frustrating fury towards him for not returning to her.
    I was so wrong not to tell, I’m in regine, tangerine dreams – Returns from frustration to a delightful tone as she remembers how she has entered an internal state of mind and that although her visons and dreams deliver a medley of both happiness and sadness, their product is an ultimate state of comfort and pleasure that she consumes and digests through her intricate recollection of memories. Nevertheless, the erratic changes in tone portrays the bipolarity of her emotional states which is common in case of mild nostalgic depression.

    Catch me if you can – Rhyming pattern of couplets develops as she now systematically jumps from one final set of memories to another, a possible vison of them playing an athletic game by the seaside,
    Working on my tan – Images of her sensually sunbathing in the light of helios while its energies gently craft a tan on her sun-kissed skin.
    Salvatore – Saviour, first allusion and reinforcement of title signifies how her lover may have had almost Jesus (God-like) qualities and the importance he would have served in saving her from a previous mental trauma or memory and that she still respects him for that.
    Dying by the hand – Death is symbolic to a passionate death or death of ones depressive emotions and the onset of more exhilarated ones referring to a deeply sexual memory.
    Of a foreign man – A reference to her lover not being American like her but Italian?
    Happily – Isolated word in structure…sums up the experience between him and her in Italy
    Calling out my name
    In the summer rain- More passionate and intimate memories deduced… this one illustrates how hearing the very acoustic sound her would have melted her heart and given her a sense of sensual pleasure.
    Ciao amore- A line that has being repeated throughout the chorus but only at the end does it make sense as she recollects and complies all her memories in her mind she now begins to release that her aspiration for his return are a hopeless dream and that she says Goodbye to her lover thanking him for everything she has done and appreciating the beauty of every memory she has with him with core memories being in the chorus.
    Salvatore can wait – Fragmented statement… Salvatore can wait in Italy signifying she no longer expects his return deducing a tone of finality.
    Now it’s time to eat
    Soft ice cream– An image of her returning back to the present and to a normal life sitting and eating ice cream indicating her resignation from the mental utopia we deconstructed above. In another perspective, as argued the soft ice cream symbolised intimate and deeply sensual memories but, in this context, ‘eat’ would mean partially deleting these memories from her memory system in attempt to completely eradicate the memories of that Italian Summer in preparation for a new love strory.

    Ah ah ah ah – Onomatopoeic lexical choices evocate the passionate flow of her mind and soul as she continues to reminisce the delightful and nostalgic memories while simultaneously experiencing the coincident feelings of grief and desperation as a result of her train of thought. In one lens, the words may mimic the sound of quivering as she deals with perpetual loss of those nostalgic memories or in another lens may elicit a vision of ecstasy where she indulges in her own sadness and enjoys its presence rather than agonise them.
    Cacciatore – Allusions to lover, possible words she might have learned been thrown into the lyrics to illustrate the random yet beautiful manner through which her train of though is flowing. Cacciotore meaning ‘Hunter’ is a symbolism of a person who provides and is adventurous which may reflect the nature of her lover and how she appreciates this manly quality.
    La da da da da
    La da da da da – Further onomatopoeic sounds and lexis that connects the flow of her thoughts by expressing her medley of feelings and emotions comprised of ecstasy, nostalgia, grief and dreaminess.
    Limousines – She may have driven around Italy in her Romeo’s limousines which visually deconstructs the image of a rich and regal lifestyle which she lived through with her lover that Summer.

    Ah ah ah ah
    Ah ah ah ah
    Ciao amore
    La da da da da
    La da da da da
    Soft ice cream – Visual Image of Ice cream symbolises Italian gelato once again showing the random yet ethereal flow of her train of though as she jumps from one memento to another all weaves and knitted together with nostalgic, ecstasy and grief. The soft ice cream may further symbolise the sensual intimacy and voluptuous memories she would have shared with her lover from classic caressing, passionate pecks and many more.

    Continue reading
    Written by: Mineka
    Page 5 of 6« First...«3456»

    ABOUT ME

    Welcome, curious wanderer! I'm Mineka, a student living in Melbourne, and this is your window to explore the depths of my intellectual journey. Delve into the realms of philosophy's timeless questions, immerse yourself in the rich tapestry of global literature, and uncover the strategies shaping modern business innovation. Join me on this intellectual odyssey as we navigate the pathways of knowledge that inspire my growth and passion. Welcome aboard!

    Popular Posts

    The Pretty Petty Ironies of Life!

    The Pretty Petty Ironies of Life!

    Economic Intuitions behind Australia’s Right to Disconnect

    Economic Intuitions behind Australia’s Right to Disconnect

    Dynamic Pricing, “Hydration” Breaks and Market Control: The Influence of US Commercial Practices in the 2026 FIFA World Cup

    Dynamic Pricing, “Hydration” Breaks and Market Control: The Influence of US Commercial Practices in the 2026 FIFA World Cup

    June 17, 2026
    Sergio Leone’s Desert of Absurdity: Extracting the Existential Philosophy of “The Good, The Bad & The Ugly”

    Sergio Leone’s Desert of Absurdity: Extracting the Existential Philosophy of “The Good, The Bad & The Ugly”

    July 22, 2024
    The Saviour From Hell? Psychological Personality Analysis Of Sienna Brooks (Inferno, 2016)

    The Saviour From Hell? Psychological Personality Analysis Of Sienna Brooks (Inferno, 2016)

    MY WRITING CORNER – CATEGORIES

    • Pulse of the World
    • Critique Corner
    • Research Desk
    • Philosophy Symposium
    • Creative Chronicles

    Open Mic – Categories

    • Current Affairs
    • History, Arts & Humanities
    • Science & Technology
    • Philosophy & Stoicism

    Lifestyle Collective – Categories

    • IN-CAFÉ CINEMA
    • IN-CAFÉ JUKEBOX
    • IN-CAFÉ LIBRARY
    • IN-CAFÉ MAP

    Recent Posts

    Dynamic Pricing, “Hydration” Breaks and Market Control: The Influence of US Commercial Practices in the 2026 FIFA World Cup

    Dynamic Pricing, “Hydration” Breaks and Market Control: The Influence of US Commercial Practices in the 2026 FIFA World Cup

    June 17, 2026
    Meaning Under Pressure: The Existential Lyrics Driving ESC 2026’s Lithuania & Czechia

    Meaning Under Pressure: The Existential Lyrics Driving ESC 2026’s Lithuania & Czechia

    May 10, 2026
    Collapsed Regimes, Nuclear Disarmament and EU Solidarity: The Hidden Politics behind 5 Eurovision Classics

    Collapsed Regimes, Nuclear Disarmament and EU Solidarity: The Hidden Politics behind 5 Eurovision Classics

    Understanding Contemporary Digital Folklore: The Case of Backrooms, Cores and Liminal Spaces

    Understanding Contemporary Digital Folklore: The Case of Backrooms, Cores and Liminal Spaces

    April 26, 2026
    The Mind Beyond the Brain: The Radical Science Behind Dan Brown’s Latest Thriller

    The Mind Beyond the Brain: The Radical Science Behind Dan Brown’s Latest Thriller

    This error message is only visible to WordPress admins

    Error: No feed found.

    Please go to the Instagram Feed settings page to create a feed.

    © 2025 copyright MINEKA'STHOUGHTTAPESTRY // All rights reserved
    Designed by LI Studio